Imagine a Bake Off contestant going into the final showstopper round and deciding to throw everything into the mix, hoping the result will prove a winner. You can almost hear Paul Hollywood saying that the result looks fantastic – before discovering a soggy bottom, an unbaked middle and a crumbling top.
This is pretty much what you get with Kneehigh Theatre’s take on Daphne Du Maurier’s classic Rebecca – an undoubted showstopper, amazing to witness and always watchable, yet often perplexing, occasionally irritating and sometimes plain silly.
Director Emma Rice’s production is a wonder to behold: a surreal vision that certainly matches the nightmare faced by the second Mrs de Winter (newcomer Imogen Sage, terrific as the awkward young wife who develops a steely determination) who happily marries Maxim only to find herself plunged into a dark world of secrecy, jealousy and mystery. Things are helped considerably by one of the most impressive sets ever to visit Brighton thanks to Leslie Travers: scenery which becomes the iconic Manderley, a windswept seashore, or a barren beach cottage with the most effortless of tweaks. The opening scene is extraordinarily breath-taking as we see a wrecked rowing boat and the lifeless body of Rebecca descend from the ceiling, setting the scene for her sinister presence to haunt the whole play.
When Kneehigh parodied Brief Encounter so brilliantly a few years back it created a loving pastiche of the film; here the 1940 Hitchcock version of Rebecca is ignored (fair enough) but the company wants to send up the book, and that isn’t quite the same thing or so obviously achievable.
Emma Rice is bound for the artistic directorship of the Globe and there is much about this production that seems suspiciously like a try-out for the kind of rabble-rousing, audience-pleasing Shakespearean drama at which the Globe excels. But in Rebecca a lot of the wild comedy moments are in danger of getting in the way of the building up of atmosphere – and, what is worse, there is a smugness to it.
The Cornish shanties and folk songs work surprisingly well to provide extra depth to certain scenes but it is hard to find the purpose for some of the dancing (not least the bizarre Wilson, Keppel and Betty sand dance routine at the fancy dress ball). The cavorting which opens Act II also destroys the tension, so it is interesting that this second half is generally so much more gripping than the first. Jasper the dog is one of those adorable puppet creations that becomes a little overused (though superbly brought to life by Ewan Wardrop, who is the real trouper of the evening, playing the caddish Jack Favell, taking up instruments, singing and dancing).
Kneehigh regular Tristan Sturrock is suitably dark and broody as Maxim, though cutting out the initial meeting between him and the second Mrs de Winter means you don’t get to see him as the carefree widower whose happiness is later contrasted with his moodiness and the dark twist to the tale.
Emily Raymond is tremendously creepy and bitter as Mrs Danvers while Andy Williams is in commanding form as the coastguard. With Lizzie Winkler as Beatrice Andy also plays Giles – the almost permanently sizzled relations who bear little resemblance to the characters in the novel, but who win many of the laughs.
Let there be no doubt: this Rebecca is eerily striking, but the dream is in danger of becoming a nightmare when the humour takes over and things become too clever for their own good.
Don’t miss out on all the latest breaking news where you live.
Here are four ways you can be sure you’ll be amongst the first to know what’s going on.
1) Make our website your homepage
2) Like our Facebook page
3) Follow us on Twitter
4) Register with us by clicking on ‘sign in’ (top right corner). You can then receive our daily newsletter AND add your point of view to stories that you read here.
And do share with your family and friends - so they don’t miss out!
Always the first with your local news.
Be part of it.